I happen to have Zoya Juicy and Yasmeen so I compared them to Reagan and Carly, from the summer collections.
Pointer and ring are Zoya Juicy, middle and pinky are Reagan. They look sort of close in the bottle, but my are they different! Juicy has a little bit of squishy jelly finish, Reagan a creme. Juicy is decidedly more strawberry, while Reagan is more fuchsia.
Pointer and ring are Carly, middle and pinky are Yasmeen. You can really see the difference here between a foil finish and a shimmer. Carly is so metallic and bright, while Yasmeen has sort of glows like a gem. Carly has wine and silvery foily bits while Yasmeen is a purple base with that similar wine shimmer.
Hope that was helpful!
Some of the products featured were sent to me for review. For additional information, please refer to my Disclosure Policy.